Modeling Broncho-pneumonia Status in Infants Using Discriminant and Logistic Regression Analyses
CHAPTER ONE
Aimย and Objectives ofย theย Study
The aim of this study is to investigate the broncho-pneumonia status in infants using linearย discriminantย andย logisticย regressionย models,ย and this will be achieved through the following objectives; by
- constructing a linear discriminant and logistic regression models that are capable for predicting the Broncho-Pneumonia status in infants;
- predicting the Broncho-Pneumonia status of some infants (random selected cases) using the developed models;
- comparing the predictive powers of the two models for Broncho-Pneumonia;
- determining the predictor that has the most discriminating ability among the predictions
CHAPTER TWO
LITERATUREย REVIEW
Introduction
ย This chapter is on the collection of relevant research works that provide a basis for the present study. It gives an overview of the prevailing theories and hypotheses and methodologies on the subject of study. A critical literature review shows how prevailing ideas fit into a particular study, and how the work agrees or differs from them.
Generalย Review
Beki (2012) used discriminant analysis and binary logistic regression for tracking the incidence of Broncho-Pulmonary Dysplasia among infants. The researcher used three possibleย predictorย variablesย i.e.ย weightย atย birth,ย weightย fourย weeksย laterย andย genderย and
builtย aย discriminantย modelย thatย isย capableย ofย trackingย Broncho-Pulmonaryย Dysplasia (BPD) infants. The Discriminant models for the two locations were;
Y=-2.860+0.035X1-0.022X2-0.658X3andY=-3.539+0.001X1-0.003X2-0.795X3ย (2.1)
Theย Logisticย regressionย modelsย forย theย twoย locationsย wereย given as;
The study predicted the BPD status of five new infants using the discriminant model in which all the five new cases were correctlyย predicted. The discriminant model built had a perfect classification of five new cases in Kaduna while it has misclassification of one of five new cases in Sokoto. Conversely, the study predicted the BPD status of five new infants using logistic model in which all the five new cases were correctly predicted or classified. Hence, the logistic model built has a classification of five new cases in Sokoto while it misclassified two of five new cases in Kaduna.
Danbaba et al (2013), carried out a research on low birth weight using logistic regression analysis to determine the prevalence of Low Birth Weight (LBW) and some of its risk factors in maternity hospitals in Wushishi Local Government of Niger State. Data from a sample of 200 live births were collected in the hospital from June โ September 2011. The data were collected by obtaining the motherโs age at birth, motherโs weight at birth, motherโs education level, motherโs occupation, gestational age, birth interval, twin or singleton birth and parity. The study fitted the logistic regression model to the data. The analysis of variance and chi-square tests were used to know the variables or factors that have statistically significant effect on birth weight at the 95.0% confidence level. The Odds Ratio (OR) of the risk factors of LBW was found using a multivariate logistic regression.
CHAPTERย THREE
Advertisements
RESEARCHย METHODOLOGY
Introduction
This chapter focuses on the methods and data collection from the study area. It is necessary to critically study our methods and procedures as a precondition for achieving the desired goals. The research explored the prediction powers of the discriminant function and the logistic model as regards to the proper applications of biomedical modeling and to compare same for classifying the Broncho-Pneumonia (BPn) status of infants.ย Theย variablesย consideredย inย thisย research;ย babyโsย weightย atย birth,ย babyโsย weight 4 weeksย after,ย babyโsย sex,ย motherโsย ageย andย motherโsย occupation areย medicallyย adequateย to elucidate the difference between a normal and Broncho-Pneumonia (BPn) patient.
In this study, the researcher shall particularly build discriminant models with prior information for predicting the Broncho-Pneumonia (BPn) status of infants using the five variables.
Assumptionsย ofย Discriminantย andย Logisticย regressionย analyses
- The predictors are not correlated with one another, e. there is no multicollinearity
- Correlation between two predictors is constant across groups.
- The variance-covariance matrixes of all the independent variables are
- Independent variable with the best discriminating ability between the two groups
- The independent variables do not need to be multivariate normal
- The dependent variable is binary
CHAPTERย FOUR
ANALYSIS,ย RESULTSย AND DISCUSSIONS
Introduction
Inย thisย chapter,ย theย dataย areย fittedย toย theย linearย discriminantย andย logisticย regressionย models. The results of the analyses are presented and discussed. The data were analyzed using SPSS version 21.0
CHAPTERย FIVE
SUMMARY,ย CONCLUSIONย AND RECOMMENDATIONS
Summary
In this study, discriminant model and binary logistic regression were used for predicting the occurrence of Broncho-pneumonia among infants using five variables as predictor variablesย i.e.ย babyโsย weightย atย birth,ย babyโsย weightย fourย weeksย after,ย babyโsย sex,ย motherโs age and motherโs occupation.
The objectives of this research are to construct the discriminant and logistic regression model that is capable of tracking BPn infants based on their variables used and also to compare and contrast the predictive power of the discriminant model and logistic regression for Broncho-Pneumonia.
The transcription and experimental method of data collection was used in this study and the research was carried out in Abuja with data obtained from University Teaching Hospital, Gwagwalada and Nasarawa with data obtained from Federal Medical Centre, Keffi. The data were gathered and tabulated for 180 and 253 low birth weight infants respectively.
Discriminant analysis and logistic regression were multivariate techniques employed for the analysis of the work. Boxโs M test and Wilkโs Lambda were used to confirm the equality of the Covariance matrices and also to confirm the significance of the canonical correlation respectively.
Conclusion
In this research, linear discriminant and logistic regression model were applied to data collected for Broncho-Pneumonia from North Central Zone taking a case study of UTH, Abuja and FMC, Keffi Nasasrawa State. The result shows that the prediction of BPn is better done with discriminant model than logistic regression model in the zone.
Ten random samples of size 10 each taken from dataset were used to test the goodness of fit of the two models developed.ย The models were used for the prediction of the BPn status of selected samples. In discriminant model the average of 7.6 is correctlyย classified, while it misclassified 2.4. The study has predicted the BPn status of selected samples using the logistic model built in which an average of 5.4 were correctlyย predicted.
Equations (4.3) and (4.5) are the developed linear discriminant and logistic regression models constructed in this study, while, the related reviewed linear dicriminant and logistic regression models were in equation (2.1)and 2.2) respectively.
Inย thisย research,ย itย wasย observedย thatย linearย discriminantย modelย hasย aย perfectย classification than Logistic regression model. We also discovered that โbabyโs weight at birthโ is the predictor that is best discriminating between the two groups
Recommendations
- The researcher recommend that the models developed in this study could assist the doctors and other health practitioners to detect and monitor the prevalence and control of BPn among infants
- Itisย recommendedย thatย theย discriminantย modelย builtย shouldย beย usedย forย BPnย cases in the zone particularly at University Teaching Hospital, Abuja and Federal Medical Centre, Keffi Nassarawa State.
- It is also recommended that larger sample size and health facilities be used infurther And use of other statistical package especially those dedicated to multivariate analysis on this area in orderย o elucidate intensive informationย or results.
- Doctors and Clinics should adopt the use of the models built in this research to discover the prevalence of BPn among infants so that adequate measures for prevention and control of Broncho-Pneumonia can be taken early enough.
Contributionย toย knowledge
This study used both baby and motherโs attributes to identify the best model used in the study while previous studies only used either the baby attributes or that of the mother.
Re-samplingย techniqueย whichย wasย achievedย throughย SPSSย packageย wasย alsoย usedย to validate the models.
The study also identified the predictor variable with the highest discrimination betweenย the two (2) groups.
References
- Anderson,ย A.ย A. (2008).ย Trackingย Broncho-pulmonaryย dysplasiaย (BPD)ย usingย the logistic regression model. International Journal of Statistics 65, 59-66.
- Anthony, J., Brooks, W. A., Malik J. S., Douglas, H. and Kim, M. E. (2010): Pneumonia research to reduce childhood mortality in the developing world. The Journal of Clinical Investigations. 2, 120-128
- Beki,ย O.ย D.ย (2012).ย Theย Useย ofย Discriminantย Modelย andย Logisticย Regressionย forย Tracking the Incidence of Broncho-Pulmonary Dysplasia among Infants. A Dissertation Submitted to Usman Danfodio University, Sokoto Nigeria.
- Carlos, A. B., Christieny, C. M., Moreira, E. L. M,, Jose, R. R and Guilherme, M. S. (2007).ย Binaryย logisticย modelย forย predictingย Broncho-ย Pulmonaryย Dysplasiaย (BPD)
- Cornfield,ย ย A.ย ย (2010).ย ย Binaryย logisticย ย modelย ย forย ย predictingย ย Myocardiaย ย infection.
- Americanย Journalย of Publicย Health,ย 81, 15-21.
- Danan,ย C.ย (2002). Gelatinaseย activitiesย inย theย airwaysย ofย prematureย infantsย and development bronchopulimonary dysplasia. American Journal of physiology, 283, 86-93.
- Danbaba, A., Audu, M., and Mahmud, A. M. (2013). Investigation of risk factors of low birth weight using multivariate logistic regression analysis: Journal of Humanities, Science and Technology. A publication of Niger State Polytechnic. 3, 59-77
- Draperย N.ย R. andย Smith, H. (1998):ย Applied Regression Analysis.ย John Wiley & Sons Inc. USA
- Emin, M. A., Levent, D., Adelet, O. and Aysu, T. (2014). Epicardial Adipose Tissue, NetrophilโTo-Lymphocyte Ratio and Platelet Lymphocyte Ratio with Diabetic Nephropathy.ย Internationalย Journalย ofย clinicalย andย experimentalย medicine.ย 7(7), 1794-1801
- Eneh,ย A.U.ย andย Ugwu,ย R.ย O.ย (2011).ย Theย Proportionย ofย Lowย Birthย Weightย Dueย toย Small Gestational Age (SGA) and Prematurity. The Internet Journal of Pediatrics and Neonatology. 13, 1-5.
- Erimafa,ย J.ย T.,ย Iduseri,ย A.ย andย Edokpa,ย I.ย W.ย (2009).ย Applicationย ofย discriminantย analysis toย predictย theย classย ofย degreeย forย graduating studentsย inย aย university system.
- Internationalย Journalย ofย Physicalย Sciences. 4(1),ย 16ย –ย 21.
- Fernaudez, P., Abbas, O., Dardenne, P. and Baeten, V. (2010).ย Discrimination of Corsican Honeyย by FT- Raman spectroscopy and Chenometrics. Journal on Biotechnology Agron Soc Environ. 15(1), 75 – 84.
- Hosmer, D. W., and Lemeshow, S. (1989). A review of goodness of fit statistics for useย inย ย ย the development of Logistic models.ย American Journal Epidemiology. 115, 92- 106.
- Hosmer, D.W. and Lemeshow, S. (2000). Applied Logistic Regression, (2ndย ed.). Wiley and Sons, inc. New York.
- Jobe,ย A.ย H.ย andย Bancalari,ย E.ย (2001).ย Broncho-pulmonaryย dysplasia.ย Americanย Journalย of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine. 163(7), 1723 – 1729.
- Kirkwood, R. B. and Stern, J. C. (2008). Essential Medical Statistics: Blackwell Science, London.
- Lange, W., Perking, H., Andersen, R. E., Royce, R., Jewell, N. and Winkel S. W. (1989). Patterns of Tโlympphocyte changes with HIVย from sero conversion to the developed of AIDS.ย Journal of Acquire Immune Defic Syndr. 2, 63-69.
- Levy, A. and Lemeshow, C. (2008). Sampling of Population (2ndย ed.).ย John Wiley, New York.
- Mobil, P., Landero, A., De-Antoni, G., Araujo, A. C., Avila-Donoso, H. and Moreno, J. (2010). Multivariate Analysis of Raman Spectra applied to microbiology: Discriminantย ofย Microorganismย atย theย speciesย level.ย Revistaย Mexicanaย De Fesica 56(5), 378-385.
- Moses, Y. O. (2007). Econometrics โA practical approachโ Daybis limited, 10 Akinola Maja Avenue, Jericho, Ibadan Nigeria.