The Influence of Employee Engagement on Public Service Delivery: A Case Study of the Nigerian Ministry of Health
Chapter One
Objectives of the Study
The broad objective of the study is to examine the role of employee engagement in improving public service delivery in the Nigerian Ministry of Health, while the specific objectives are to:
- Assess the current level of employee engagement within the Nigerian Ministry of Health.
- Investigate the factors influencing employee engagement in the Ministry of Health.
- Analyze the relationship between employee engagement and the quality of healthcare service delivery.
CHAPTER TWO
LITERATURE REVIEW
Chapter Two provides a comprehensive review of the key concepts, theoretical frameworks, and empirical studies related to employee engagement in public sector organisations. It begins with an exploration of the Conceptual Framework, defining and critiquing key concepts such as employee engagement, public service motivation, psychological ownership, and service-oriented performance. The Theoretical Framework follows, presenting two relevant theories—the Public Service Motivation theory and the Job Demands-Resources model—along with their relevance and critiques. The Empirical Review summarizes recent studies on employee engagement, while the Literature Gap highlights areas for future research, particularly in the context of Nigerian public organisations.
Conceptual Framework
Employee Engagement
Employee engagement refers to the level of commitment, enthusiasm, and emotional investment that an employee has towards their work and organisation. It represents the extent to which employees are involved in their tasks, motivated to contribute to organisational goals, and feel a sense of purpose in their work. Engaged employees are generally more productive, loyal, and committed to their roles within the organisation (De Simone et al., 2016).
Cooke, Brant, and Woods (2019) defined employee engagement as the harnessing of organisational members’ selves to their work roles. This conceptualization implies that engagement is not just about satisfaction, but about the emotional, cognitive, and physical energy employees invest in their roles. According to the Job Demands-Resources (JD-R) Model, engagement is shaped by the balance between job demands and available resources (Cooke, Brant, & Woods, 2019). When employees perceive their work environment as supportive, with adequate resources, their engagement levels tend to increase. This model suggests that both job-related challenges and personal resources such as resilience and motivation play crucial roles in fostering engagement (De Simone et al., 2016).
While employee engagement is widely acknowledged as essential for improving organisational performance, it can be influenced by various external factors such as the work environment and leadership styles, making it challenging to measure consistently. For instance, the presence of a supportive leader can significantly boost engagement, while a toxic work culture can reduce it (Hammon, Gillis, & Icenogle, 2022). Additionally, while engagement is often linked to high performance, it can sometimes lead to burnout if not properly managed, as employees may become overly committed and overextend themselves (Chiwawa, 2022).
CHAPTER THREE
METHODOLOGY
Advertisements
Research Design
Research design refers to the overall structure or blueprint of a research study, outlining the processes of data collection, analysis, and interpretation to achieve the study’s objectives. For this study, a correlational research design was chosen due to its suitability for understanding relationships between variables. Correlational designs aim to assess the strength and direction of relationships between two or more variables without manipulating them. Specifically, the study aimed to assess employee engagement within the Nigerian Ministry of Health and its impact on healthcare service delivery. A correlational design was ideal for understanding how employee engagement affects service delivery outcomes without the need for experimental manipulation (Saunders, Lewis, & Thornhill, 2019).
This design was selected because it allows the study to explore the association between employee engagement factors and healthcare quality, which were not under the researcher’s control. Correlational research is effective in identifying patterns and relationships between variables in natural settings, providing insights that are highly applicable to real-world scenarios. The aim was not to establish causality but to evaluate the strength of associations between engagement and service delivery, offering valuable insights for policy recommendations (Bell, Bryman, & Harley, 2019).
Study Area
The geographical setting for this study was the Nigerian Ministry of Health, specifically focusing on its various offices located across major Nigerian cities. The Ministry of Health is responsible for overseeing public health policies and healthcare service delivery in Nigeria, making it a crucial site for understanding the relationship between employee engagement and healthcare outcomes. The study aimed to capture responses from employees across different regions to obtain a comprehensive view of engagement levels and their effects on healthcare service quality.
The selected locations included Abuja (the capital), Lagos, and Port Harcourt, cities with significant health infrastructure and diverse health-related challenges. These settings provided an adequate representation of employees from both central and regional offices, ensuring a broad perspective on engagement within the Ministry. According to Creswell and Creswell (2018), choosing diverse settings enhances the external validity of the study, making the findings more generalizable across similar contexts in the Nigerian health sector.
Population of the Study
The population of this study comprised employees within the Nigerian Ministry of Health, specifically those involved in administrative, clinical, and operational roles. The total population size was approximately 2,000 employees across the Ministry’s branches. The rationale for targeting this population was based on the Ministry’s crucial role in healthcare delivery in Nigeria. Employees in various roles, ranging from medical professionals to administrative staff, were likely to have differing levels of engagement and perceptions of healthcare service quality.
By selecting employees from diverse functions within the Ministry, the study aimed to capture a comprehensive understanding of how engagement levels might vary based on role and how these variations influenced service delivery. According to Bell (2022), understanding the characteristics of the population is essential in selecting an appropriate sample and in making valid inferences about the broader group. Given that employee engagement can vary across job categories, including clinical staff, administrative personnel, and managerial roles, the chosen population was broad enough to reflect these differences.
CHAPTER FOUR
DATA PRESENTATION AND ANALYSIS
Data Presentation
Table 4.1: Demographic Distribution of Respondents
CHAPTER FIVE
SUMMARY, CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS
Summary of Findings
The research aimed to explore the impact of employee engagement on the quality of healthcare service delivery in the Nigerian Ministry of Health. After a thorough analysis of the collected data, several key findings emerged, shedding light on how different factors influence employee engagement and, consequently, the quality of healthcare services provided by the Ministry. The research focused on various variables, including employee engagement itself, organisational support, training and development, the work environment, and the relationship between these factors and the delivery of healthcare services. This section provides a summary of these findings.
The first major finding of the study was the significant positive relationship between employee engagement and the quality of healthcare service delivery. The analysis revealed that employees who were more engaged with their work tended to deliver higher quality healthcare services. Engaged employees were found to exhibit higher levels of commitment to their roles, a stronger sense of responsibility, and an overall improved work ethic. They were also more likely to go beyond the basic requirements of their roles, which had a direct impact on the quality of services they provided. This finding emphasizes the importance of fostering an environment where employees are motivated, committed, and passionate about their roles in delivering healthcare services. The higher the employee engagement, the more likely it was that healthcare services met the expected standards of quality, highlighting the crucial role engagement plays in the success of the healthcare system.
Another significant finding of the study was the role of organisational support in enhancing employee engagement. Employees who felt supported by their organisation, particularly by leadership, were more likely to be engaged in their work. Organisational support, in this context, refers to the resources, encouragement, and recognition that employees receive from the organisation to help them succeed in their roles. This support was shown to have a direct and positive effect on employee motivation, job satisfaction, and overall engagement. Employees who felt that their organisation valued their contributions and provided the necessary tools and resources for success reported higher levels of engagement, which, in turn, positively impacted the quality of healthcare services. This finding highlights the importance of leadership in shaping the work environment and fostering a culture of support and appreciation that encourages employees to perform at their best.
Training and development emerged as another important factor influencing employee engagement. The study found that employees who had access to training and development opportunities were more likely to be engaged in their work. Training and development initiatives provide employees with the skills and knowledge they need to excel in their roles, which can lead to increased job satisfaction and a greater sense of accomplishment. Employees who feel that their employer is investing in their professional growth are more likely to be motivated and committed to their work. However, while training and development were important for employee engagement, they did not have as significant an impact as organisational support or the work environment. This suggests that while training and development are crucial, they should be complemented by other factors, such as strong leadership and a supportive work environment, to maximize their effectiveness in fostering employee engagement.
The work environment was also found to play a key role in determining employee engagement. Employees who worked in a positive, supportive, and well-resourced environment reported higher levels of engagement. The work environment in this study encompassed both physical and social factors, such as the availability of resources, the quality of the relationships between colleagues and supervisors, and the overall organisational culture. A positive work environment, where employees feel safe, respected, and supported, was shown to enhance employee motivation and commitment to their work. This, in turn, led to higher levels of engagement and improved healthcare service delivery. The work environment was found to be one of the most significant predictors of employee engagement, highlighting the importance of creating a workplace that supports employee well-being and fosters positive interactions.
The study also found that employee engagement had a direct impact on the quality of healthcare service delivery. Engaged employees were more likely to provide high-quality services, as they demonstrated a stronger sense of responsibility, higher motivation, and a greater commitment to their work. The analysis showed that engaged employees were not only more productive but also more innovative in their approach to delivering services. They were willing to go the extra mile to ensure that patients received the best care possible, which ultimately contributed to better healthcare outcomes. This finding underscores the importance of focusing on employee engagement as a means of improving service delivery within the healthcare sector.
Furthermore, the study highlighted the importance of public service motivation in enhancing employee engagement. Public service motivation refers to the intrinsic motivation that employees feel to serve the public good. Employees who are driven by a strong sense of public service motivation were found to be more engaged in their work, as they felt a greater sense of purpose and responsibility in their roles. This motivation was shown to have a significant impact on the quality of healthcare service delivery, as employees who are motivated by a desire to make a positive difference are more likely to deliver exceptional services. The findings suggest that fostering a sense of public service motivation among employees can be an effective strategy for improving employee engagement and, by extension, healthcare service delivery.
In terms of the relationships between the variables, the study found that employee engagement was strongly influenced by organisational support, the work environment, and training and development. While all three factors had a positive impact on employee engagement, organisational support and the work environment were identified as the most significant predictors. This finding emphasizes the need for organisations to prioritize these factors when designing strategies to enhance employee engagement. By providing employees with the necessary resources, creating a supportive work environment, and investing in their professional development, organisations can foster higher levels of engagement and, consequently, improve the quality of healthcare services.
Overall, the findings of the study suggest that employee engagement is a critical factor in improving the quality of healthcare service delivery in the Nigerian Ministry of Health. Engaged employees are more likely to deliver high-quality services, and factors such as organisational support, the work environment, and training and development all play crucial roles in enhancing engagement. The study highlights the importance of creating a supportive and motivating work environment for healthcare employees, as this can have a direct impact on the quality of services provided. Furthermore, the findings suggest that strategies aimed at improving employee engagement, such as providing adequate organisational support and fostering a positive work environment, should be prioritized in order to achieve better healthcare outcomes. These findings provide valuable insights for policymakers and healthcare administrators seeking to improve the performance of the healthcare system in Nigeria.
Conclusion
Based on the results of the hypotheses tested, several key conclusions can be drawn regarding the impact of employee engagement on the quality of healthcare service delivery in the Nigerian Ministry of Health. The first hypothesis, which posited that there is no significant relationship between the level of employee engagement and the quality of healthcare service delivery, was rejected. The findings revealed a significant positive relationship between employee engagement and healthcare quality, indicating that higher employee engagement leads to better service delivery.
The second hypothesis, suggesting that factors such as job satisfaction, organisational support, and professional development opportunities do not significantly influence employee engagement, was also rejected. The analysis demonstrated that organisational support and training and development significantly enhanced employee engagement, underlining the importance of a supportive and resource-rich work environment.
Lastly, the third hypothesis, which argued that higher levels of employee engagement do not lead to improved healthcare service delivery, was also disproven. The results confirmed that engaged employees were more likely to provide higher quality healthcare services, emphasizing the importance of fostering engagement to improve service outcomes.
In conclusion, the study highlights the critical role of employee engagement in improving healthcare service delivery. It underscores the need for the Nigerian Ministry of Health to focus on enhancing employee engagement through organisational support, professional development, and a positive work environment to achieve better healthcare outcomes.
Recommendations
Based on the findings of the study, the following recommendations are made to enhance employee engagement and improve the quality of healthcare service delivery in the Nigerian Ministry of Health:
- Invest in Employee Engagement Programs” The study found a significant positive relationship between employee engagement and the quality of healthcare service delivery. It is therefore recommended that the Nigerian Ministry of Health invest in comprehensive employee engagement programs. These programs should focus on fostering a sense of commitment, motivation, and belonging among employees, which can directly improve their performance and the quality of services they provide.
- Strengthen Organisational Support: Organisational support was identified as a key factor influencing employee engagement. The Ministry should prioritize providing robust support systems for healthcare workers, including access to adequate resources, recognition programs, and a supportive work environment. Ensuring that employees feel valued and supported can lead to increased job satisfaction and higher levels of engagement, ultimately improving service delivery.
- Enhance Training and Development Opportunities: The findings indicate that training and development significantly impact employee engagement. It is recommended that the Ministry invest in continuous professional development opportunities for healthcare workers, including workshops, certifications, and leadership training. Providing these opportunities will not only enhance employee skills but also foster a sense of personal growth, increasing engagement levels and improving the quality of healthcare services.
- Foster a Positive Work Environment: The work environment was found to have a significant influence on employee engagement. The Ministry should work on creating a positive, collaborative, and inclusive work environment where healthcare workers feel safe, respected, and empowered. This could involve promoting teamwork, effective communication, and providing employees with the tools and support they need to excel in their roles.
- Promote Work-Life Balance: To sustain high levels of employee engagement, it is essential to consider work-life balance as a contributing factor. The Ministry should implement policies that allow healthcare workers to manage their work schedules effectively, offering flexibility where possible. This could help reduce burnout, improve job satisfaction, and maintain a high level of engagement, ultimately benefiting both employees and the quality of healthcare services provided.
Limitations of the Study
One of the key limitations of this study is its reliance on self-reported data from employees within the Nigerian Ministry of Health, which may be subject to response bias or inaccuracies, as participants may provide socially desirable answers rather than objective reflections of their experiences. Additionally, the study focused on a specific geographic region and sector, limiting the generalizability of the findings to other areas or industries in Nigeria. The sample size, although adequate for statistical analysis, may not fully capture the diversity of the entire healthcare workforce, as it was not randomly selected across all healthcare institutions in the country. Furthermore, the study employed cross-sectional data, which does not allow for the assessment of causal relationships over time. Finally, factors such as organisational politics, leadership styles, and external pressures were not included in the analysis, which may have also influenced employee engagement and healthcare service delivery. These limitations suggest that the findings should be interpreted with caution, and future research could address these gaps by using longitudinal designs, expanding the sample size, and considering additional variables that could impact the outcomes.
References
- Alamri, M. (2023). Transformational leadership and work engagement in public organisations: Promotion focus and public service motivation. Leadership & Organisation Development Journal, 44(1), 137–155. https://doi.org/10.1108/loDJ-07-2022-0175
- Alqhaiwi, Z. O., & Luu, T. (2023). Workplace spirituality and service-oriented performance via work engagement in public organisations: The moderating role of service climate. Public Management Review. https://doi.org/10.1080/14719037.2023.2239245
- Brennan, A., et al. (2023). A conservation of resources perspective on public sector employee work engagement. European Management Review. https://doi.org/10.1111/emre.12594
- Buriro, S., et al. (2018). Psychological ownership and employee engagement. In A. H. Jantan (Ed.), Perspectives in Organisational Behaviour(pp. 71–83). Serdang, Malaysia: Universiti Putra Malaysia Press.
- Chiwawa, N. (2022). Determinants of employee engagement in public sector organisations: Case of Zimbabwe. International Journal of Public Sector Management, 35(7), 749–764.
- Cooke, D. K., Brant, K. K., & Woods, J. M. (2019). The role of public service motivation in employee work engagement: A test of the Job Demands-Resources Model. International Journal of Public Administration, 42(9), 765–775.
